Where to place (best) cleats for the boats jib sheets

As I reach the point in restoring two M-11's , I'm not sure where to place the jib lead car (block) and cam-cleat for the jib sheets.. The idea of trial and error,(placing multiple holes in my boats) doesn't appeal to me..lol.. pictures, etc. would be very much appreciated.

soapy

sail_and_oar's picture

Locally to where I sail there a two quite disinct cuts of Mirror jib. Old boats which are falling to pieces (like mine) normally use a high clewed jib which has a long luff which extends full length of the forestay. The whizzy race boats all seem to use dark red mini genoas with sail windows. I think the foot and leech lengths are the same but the luff of the race boats is much shorter.

The old type jibs normally sheet to fairleads on the side tank tops and the race boats tend to put their fairleads on the centre thwart, one each side. Setting up the jib fairleads is described in Guy Wilkin's book "Mirror Racing" He suggests 2metres from the jib tack and an angle of 14 degrees from the centreline. If the book is out of print there are secondhand copies in Amazon for less than £3 delivered to the UK. Highly reccommended by me.

As an alternative contact the sailmaker who made the jib

If you fix into the side tank tops you will need something stronger than the 5mm ply to screw into. You could bodge it like I did and glue a ply pad onto the top of the tank or do the job properly by fitting a pad in from underneath.

Once you have the fairleads in place you can fit the cam cleats. The sheet needs to pass from the fairlead over the centre of the two cams of the cam cleat and directly into your hand. When you adjust the jib sheet you will probably have the tiller extension and mainsheet in your "aft" hand and you adjust the jib sheet with your "fore" hand. Choose some cleats which comfortably hold the size of sheet you are using. Quite a big cleat is needed for a 10mm sheet. Our local racers use 7mm but I like comfort and my big hands can't grip thin rope.

Getting the relationship between the fairlead and the cleat correct will take a little trial and error and it might be worth screwing the fittings into a piece of wood and trying out your jib sheet in them before drilling the boat. The gap between the fairlead and the cleat needs to be sensible (about an inch and a half) and you might find you need spacers under the cleat to raise it up. You can make these from plywood to the same shape as the base plate of the cam cleat or buy them from the manufacturer of the cleat.

Be careful if you dismantle the cleats. Sometimes the springs jump out. Make sure all the bits are put back in the right order the right way up.

When you are sure on the positions drill the boat. Put a little bit of varnish down the holes to seal up the wood and screw them down with stainless steel screws. The screws don't need to be very tight, just wind them in nicely but check them from time to time to make sure they are not becoming loose. The wood will stretch and shrink as it becomes wet then dry and it will take a while for everything to bed in nicely.

Cliff

curlew's picture

Hi Cliff
My old type fairleads are on the gunwale, with the sheet outside the shrouds. I sometimes try pulling the sheet inboard a bit, which might help, but have not found a way of achieving this conveniently. I then find that, when running, the jib sheet is trapped inside the shrouds, which hooks the sail.
David

sail_and_oar's picture

Where to mount the fairleads is always going to be a compromise. The reasons I moved mine were that the original fairlead had no provision for a cleat and from the suggestions in Guy Wilkin's book. Certainly as David suggested the sail becomes hooked when running. I've tried booming the jib out to leeward and I think it might help a bit in light winds. Booming it out to windward really powers everything up. I'd be sad to be without my jibstick.

Cliff

soapysails's picture

Thanks for the lead to Guy Wilkins book and for your comments.

soapy

PuffinInTegel's picture

For years, Puffin's jibsheet fairleads and cleats sat on aluminium plates screwed to the gunwales at the same general position as on most older Mirrors, see below:
the old man at sea
I had intended to move them inboard to improve upwind performance (i.e. sail a few degrees higher upwind), but shirked the effort. While I was painting the bottom in 2011, the trestles under my boat tipped over, resulting in two holes in the side tanks:
holy deck!
Thus I had reason to put patches on the deck anyway and decided to use these as reinforced mounts for the jam-cleat/fairlead combination:
new fairlead mounts
I never used a compass to check how close to the wind I can sail, but I do have the feeling that it has helped to move them inboard. As I sail on lakes and rivers most of the year, this is important for saving you a few tacks when you're going upwind on narrow stretches of water, especially if you are obliged by law to dodge all commercial shipping such as the '#@&$$! excursion boats.
Gernot H.

soapysails's picture

Gernot, your pic's are truly helpful ! How to "Kick Back" was great :) (shows you just enjoying the sun in the boat while being towed) In any case, the more pictures, the better..they save some of us from asking too many questions. Shots showing rigging, etc. I noticed for instance, that you have a bow line/painter attachment. Where you able to drill through the "V" board without entering the bow box ?

62816inBerlin's picture

The painter attachment was already there when I bought "Puffin".
The picture was taken while anchored after swimming on the last day of the first "JollenFlottille" meeting in 2010. It is in the report http://mirrordiscussforum.org/documents/stories/Jollen-Flotille_2010.pdf which, unfortunately, I have never rewritten in English. It does contain a lot of pretty pictures, though.
We were towed home from Zingst to Barth by the "motorized" participants on the evening of the first day, though. Our outing even made it into a glossy sailing magazine in that year ("Segeln" 10/2010, Pp. 90 ... 93 which started with the following picture:
Title page
Someone had taken a picture of me taking a picture ! Now that the magazine's copyright has expired, Daniel, the author, has re-published the article on his home page at http://retrosailing.npage.de/jollen_flottille_2010_98201360.html .
Everything battened down for the winter?
Cheers,
Gernot.

sail_and_oar's picture

I think it has a different name but it's the lump of hardwood on the front of the bow transom for the forestay chainplate screws to fasten into. Many Mirrors had a fitting for a painter here (mine included). It was usually an eye plate fastened to the boat with four screws. The original Mirrors used an identical part for the forestay and shroud anchors.

Drilling a hole of a precise depth is often done by wrapping sticky tape around the drill bit as a depth gauge. I would aim to drill just the hardwood and not the ply behind it. If the process all goes to pieces and you end up poking the drill all the way through it is far from a disaster. Annoint the inside of the hole with a piece of wire dipped in epoxy then trowel/squeeze some thickened epoxy into the hole with the corner of something shaped like a credit card. As you drive the screw in it will push the thickened epoxy down the hole and seal everything up. As usual all drilled holes for fittings should be sealed with glue or varnish to prevent/delay rot. Stainless steel screws are far better than brass.

In my experience attaching a painter here can be a bit awkward as if you drop it over the side it's tricky to get it back on board. If one wants to anchor or pick up a mooring this becomes more significant. It's also not good to have trailing lines if you use an outboard.

I prefer to tie my painter around the base of the mast with an anchor bend (don't tie in the halyard tails!). I have a fairlead on the bow. If I drop my painter I can recover it from the base of the mast. I normally lead the painter back to the cockpit outside the shroud so I can drop an anchor or sail up to a mooring without having to work on the foredeck.

Cliff

soapysails's picture

Thanks boys.. I like the mast base idea.. the less holes, the better :)

sail_and_oar's picture

"Thanks boys.. I like the mast base idea.. the less holes, the better :)"

Sorry but you'll need a fairlead for which you'll need to drill the boat.

I have one on the centreline, David (Curlew) has one on each bow transom corner. David's system is probably better. Make sure it will be compatable with your boat cover.

Cliff

soapysails's picture

a pic of each set would be nice..just to see what and where.

again
thanks

sail_and_oar's picture

I havn't got to grips with putting pictures on this website but if you put into google "Solent Cruising Guide" a list will pop up and somewhere near the top will be my Solent pilot "The Solent, a cruising guide for centereboard boats". There is a fuzzy picture in the River Hamble section of me being towed by a Wayfarer. The painter is tied around the mast and goes over the bow through a wooden fairlead which is part of my oar carrier. This fitting remains unchanged. I'm not sure of the date of the photo but I've not taken a tow since 2006 so I guess it is well tested. Back in those days my Mirror was virtually a second home. I'd spend 20 or 30 nights on board over the course of the year, mostly weekends plus perhaps one or two cruises of 4 to 7 days. I spend less time with the Mirror these days. I might have managed 12 nights this year.

One of the interesting things about the position of the fairlead is that the further off centre it is fitted the more quietly a boat will lie at anchor. With the fairlead on the centreline the boat will swing through about 90 degrees every 10 seconds or so but as you move it off centre the boat will sheer around much less.

There is a beach we like to stop at which faces north. In a westerly wind anchoring from the beach is a bit awkward as the boat will usually swing about and end up drying out if the tide is falling. If one anchors as normal but then ties a line to the anchor line about 8 feet out and brings this back to the port rowlock it will have the effect of a fairlead fitted to the port gunwale just forward of the mast. The boat will usually lie very quietly and the wind will blow against the port side of the boat and help keep it off the beach. The longer the anchor line the better. I did this a while ago and a couple of guys managed to sail straight over the anchor line with their 29er, caught it with their daggerboard and capsized. It was extremely funny but the guys didn't much appreciate my suggestion that they might do a bit better if they got themselves a Skipper 14. I didn't tell them it was my anchor line that had tripped them. They've probably forgiven me by now.

Cliff

sail_and_oar's picture

The picture which pops up with all of David's messages shows the two fairleads on the bow corners. Probably easier to reach from the cockpit than my system. There's no right or wrong, if it works it's OK but it's a bit heartbreaking when a carefully crafted modification is built and found to be useless when you come to test it. I've built dozens over the years. Most of them ended up in the bin and my boat is slowly returning to somewhere near how it was originally designed. Modifications normally eat into a boat's performance but some are necessary.

Cliff

curlew's picture

I made the fairleads out of hardwood, and bolted them right through. Most of my critical fixings are bolted through - forestay and chain plates for instance. I drill an oversize hole, coat it inside with epoxy using a baby bud, then insert the bolt once it is hard. You can see the fairleads in my "Mirror Mods" video at the following URL (44 seconds in):-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R1Ny7r9P5OQ
Sorry, I don't know how to upload a photograph here.
David

Hi David,

Being a Mirror expert I have to tell you that your Mirror is out of class. You know what an expert is don't you? An expert is a person who with great skill is able to shoot water out of a bodily orifice. Which orifice you ask? In my case the mouth. :-> If my fellow Mirror sailors in the Ontario Mirror Dinghy Association would hear of me proclaiming expertise they would fall over laughing,

My Mirror also is out of class and I don't care one wit. I do admire your modifications and it was great to see you in the video. Most of the people on this forum are faceless to us.

Pete

sail_and_oar's picture

I have no claim to fame but I was included as an extra in David's video "Trip to Bembridge". I'm the one waving to the camera from 1 minute 20 seconds.

There are a few photos of me in the Solent Pilot I described earlier in this thread. Time hasn't improved my looks.

Videos such as David's recording development work are extremely important. They guide those of us who follow.

Cliff