sailing the mirror

Hello,
I am a new member and couldn't find a suitable forum for this request... so picked the one with most traffic apologize if out of line. Please redirect if best.

We are considering replacing the Opti dinghy in our sail training program. We are considering the mirror but concerned that it would not be suitable for the younger children (8 yrs). At that age we sail two to a boat and would use the depowered cat sail configuration but still not sure if it would be suitable for the youngsters.

Any advice would be welcome

Jon Healey
Past Commodore
Salt Spring Island Sailing Club

62816inBerlin's picture

Hello Jon,
Keep the optis and get a Mirror or two for the more experienced kids!
I think a pair of 8-year-olds who have sailed optis a lot could be comfortable in a Mirror provided it's not blowing too hard. However I am no expert on the subject.
I suggest you contact Woollahra Mirrors in Australia (https://www.facebook.com/pages/Woollahra-Mirrors/254187364630698?fref=ts ). A look at the pictures they have on Facebook makes up for a lot of explanations. I judge some of the kids to be in the 7-12 age bracket.
kids at Woollahra Mirrors

If you are not in FaceBook, I could probably establish contacts with one of the club's members.
I hope this helps.
Gernot H.

With the cat sail rig (which I've never tried), I've heard that the Mirror's hard to tack and tends to get stuck in irons, so I'd avoid it. The jib doesn't add a lot of power anyway, and what it does add can be removed at any time just by letting it flap, so it really isn't a problem having it there. If you've got two people to a boat, there's also not much for the second one to do other than shift their weight around, and that risks making it dull (a problem shared by putting two to an Optimist), so it would be better to reef the mainsail in stronger winds and retain the jib. In lighter winds, two 8-year-olds should be able to handle a Mirror with ease anyway (just as a 4-year-old can handle an Opti), and if the wind gets up too much they can learn to spill wind if they have to (from the mainsail). If it gets scary, they can be taught how to heave to and wait for a squall to pass (if there's enough room to play with), or else go head to wind and lower the mainsail (which is a bit safer with the newer rig as there's no gaff to fall on heads, but if you train them properly a gaff isn't a real threat in any case - it's only a danger if an idiot lets go of the halyard, and even then you can train them to get their heads forwards and down in such an emergency where the gaff can't reach them).

The best way to start them off would be to team up one younger child with an older one, at which point there's also a much greater opportunity for knowledge to be transferred. This will depend on the quality of the older ones though - not all will have the right attitude to be suitable for this kind of mentoring role, though the ones that are good at it will find that they gain a lot from doing so. Send the less useful older ones out in Optis to race on their own. The helming should be shared 50:50. Spinnakers are also fun to play with, and again that makes it a good idea to mix the ages so that there's always enough experience on the boat to cope with them, while the beginner will gain expertise really quickly and find the whole experience much more interesting and rewarding.

I agree with Gernot that the Optis should be retained if possible, even if you're shifting the main focus of the training to the Mirrors, but my preference would be to use the Mirrors the most simply because the learning can be accelerated by having an experienced older child training a younger one. All the children should be taught to share what they know with others too and not to be keep it selfishly to themselves - if you win races by using knowledge which your rivals in other boats don't have, you aren't being pushed as hard as you should be and you'll lose out yourself as a result, so the whole atmosphere needs to be built upon the idea of sharing knowledge. The pairings can be changed from time to time too, and that will help all the knowledge to spread around.

You also need to keep it fun though - there's no need to go to either of the extremes. Some clubs are obsessed with racing and push the training too hard, thereby killing all enjoyment and putting lots of children off, while others try to do the opposite and fail to bring any of them on. The middle road is best, and top racers will still emerge out of it while everyone has a better time. Some of the ideas in http://www.rya.org.uk/sitecollectiondocuments/training/Web%20Documents/R... may be of use to you, and the Optis could be useful for many of them.